Nextstep wins
Tuesday, August 28th, 2007This article references this article which asserts that:
- When you copy a directory into a place which already has a directory of this name, Windows 95+ asks you if you want to "replace" the directory. If you say yes, it replaces the individual files, i.e. merges the new directory into the old
- On Mac OS X it also asks you if you want to replace the directory, but this actually deletes the old directory first
- That the Windows behaviour is better as it's less destructive, and other reasons
I have a number of comments about this:
- Independent of if the Windows behaviour is better, the word "replace" implies the Mac behaviour. I have been confused by this before (assuming that if I click "yes" to the "replace" question that it will delete the contents of the destination first, i.e. replace them)
- There are times when you want merge (merging photos from a digital camera) and times when you want replace (replacing one source tree with another)
- Nextstep would ask you if you want to replace the destination, or merge (or cancel)
Surely Nextstep's solution is the best. Maybe asking is annoying, but both Windows and Mac evidently ask a question as well, so Nextstep is not worse in that respect.
Just one more example of how technology gets worse with time. Or at least not better anyway, on average.